My rating: 2.5 of 5 stars
Publication Date: September 1st 2015
Publisher: HMH Books for Young Readers
Point of View: 1st Person & Female
Recommended Age: 13+
Genres & Themes: Young Adult, Historical Fiction, Western, Adventure, Revenge
When Kate Thompson’s father is killed by the notorious Rose Riders for a mysterious journal that reveals the secret location of a gold mine, the eighteen-year-old disguises herself as a boy and takes to the gritty plains looking for answers and justice. What she finds are devious strangers, dust storms, and a pair of brothers who refuse to quit riding in her shadow. But as Kate gets closer to the secrets about her family, she gets closer to the truth about herself and must decide if there’s room for love in a heart so full of hate. In the spirit of True Grit, the cutthroat days of the Wild West come to life for a new generation.
Kate’s father was murdered by the Rose Riders, a notorious Western gang. Ergo, she decides to run after the said gang and avenge her father; she has a vendetta. But finding which doesn’t want to be found can be tedious. Luckily, Kate doesn’t have to follow the road of vengeance alone; two young men are continuously trailing her, not far behind.
I had the feeling that this would be a perfect medley of genres, blending, inter alia, adventure, historical fiction and a subtle drop of romance to spice everything up. While the author did exploit those genres and inserted some themes along the way, this book was repetitious as hell. The setting, while it technically did vary, didn’t feel to me like it ever did. The pacing was stable but one problem: it was slow. Slow plus monotonous do not make a great combination.
The idea, sincerely, was promising. Revenge stories are ordinarily narrated by fierce, sometimes feral or manipulative, but always ambitious heroes/heroines. That’s what I like most about them. That’s what I liked most about Kate. There was so little she was afraid of… and I don’t even recall her being frightened by anything. She was human, nothing like a robot or an animated object bleak of emotions, but impressively courageous.
Since at that time and place people used accents, the characters had them, too. Nothing annoying or overly present, just the right amount of distorted words to add authenticity and fidelity to the historical setting.
I guess if you enjoy Western movies and stories in general, you might not have the same struggle with this book as I did. I am not one to seek this type of story, but I wanted to know what it felt like to read one. And I did, but I also realized that cowboys aren’t as exciting to me as they are to other people.
Still, it intrigued me and there were some good twists; Erin Bowman clearly wasn’t reticent to shake things up!
Glad there were some good twists despite the repetition. Sorry this wasn’t a better read for you.
I haven’t really read a revenge story yet but it’s an interesting topic, soeey to see this one didn’t really work for you.
Aww I’m sorry it didn’t work out for you, but I’m really glad you still decided to pick it up. I find this book so intriguing, and while I’m not the one to indulge in westerns, I want to dive into a story that would be a bit fresh for me. I heard pretty good things so far, so crossing my fingers it’ll work out for me!
I don’t mind watching Western movies, but I don’t think I would like it translated in book form! Sorry to see that you didn’t like it! I can see how this could be repetitive based on the blurb. But man, it has a really nice cover 😛
Sorry this one didn’t work out for you 😦 westerns are so hit or miss for me, I prefer to read sci-fi (which are basically westerns in space lol) instead of the traditional type. At least this wasn’t a complete failure and had some good points 🙂
“Slow plus monotonous do not make a great combination.” Oooh, no, they definitely do not. I can see myself having problems with that as well. I did love True Grit (the movie) so I have no idea how I would take this one.
Aw I’m sorry that you didn’t like this one as much as you would’ve hoped, Lola! I’m not a huge fan of slow moving books myself so I’ll definitely keep that in mind when heading into this one.
Nice review, gal <33
Aaahh.. well this sucks 😦 You are such a tough cookie, and I thought I was one haha 😀 I’m not sure about reading a slow moving books but atleast the twists kept the story going. Fantastic, honest review as always Lola 🙂