Review: Manga Classics: The Scarlet Letter by Stacy King, Nathaniel Hawthorne, Crystal Chan & SunNeko Lee


Manga Classics: The Scarlet Letter by Stacy King

My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Received: NetGalley
Publication Date: March 10th 2015
Publisher: Udon Entertainment
Point of View: /
Genres & Themes: Young Adult, Historical, Religion, Manga, Classics

BLURB:

A powerful tale of forbidden love, shame, and revenge comes to life in Manga Classics: The Scarlet Letter. Faithfully adapted by Crystal Chan from the original novel, this new edition features stunning artwork by SunNeko Lee (Manga Classics: Les Miserables) which will give old and new readers alike a fresh insight into the Nathaniel Hawthorne’s tragic saga of Puritan America.

Manga Classics editions feature classic stories, faithfully adapted and illustrated in manga style, and available in both hardcover and softcover editions.

Proudly presented by UDON Entertainment and Morpheus Publishing.

REVIEW:

Having not read the original classic, I had no expectations whatsoever regarding the story or any element related to it. I did, however, wish, as I do whenever I start reading a manga, for the graphics to be beautiful and for them to make us clearly understand the actions of the characters.

In this case, those two conditions were fulfilled, so I did enjoy my reading of this novel. Still, perhaps it would have been better for me to read the original classic novel before starting this manga, for I had trouble here and there understanding the characters. I felt like they were barely presented and some of their actions out of their personality or simply unjustified. For example, there was this scene in which Pearl, Hester’s daughter, turned evil-like and seemed to not even recognize her mother, and that only because this latter took her ‘‘A’’ letter off her chest. That was just…weird.

It’s like every character, except for Hester, had this double personality, which I thought was thought-provoking but so poorly explained or given detail on that I mostly got confused when trying to make links and ‘‘get it’’. Period. Other than that, the story felt rushed, very rushed. A fast-pacing is most certainly a good thing when reading a story including action, adventure but, since this aimed a focus on the psychological aspect of characters, I don’t think it was such a great idea. It was like the author started a subject and then BAM, a new scene was inserted. Manga’s fault or not, it should have been slower.

Funny how the romance left me emotionless. I had no idea how him (to not spoil you) fell in love, why they loved each other ‘‘so much’’ as for Hester to keep the name of her lover hidden from everyone and, especially, how she could have concealed her feelings for him from everyone for so long. Basically, I just wasn’t convinced. They did not look unconditionally in love.

Lack of dept characterization-wise, realism in the romance, adequate pacing and detail for the story aside, as a whole this was enjoyable and pretty captivating despite all its flaws. Plus, let’s not forget the beautiful drawings!

I wouldn’t recommend actually buying this book if, like me, you have not read The Scarlet Letter as a novel before, because, in my opinion, the story told in this manga format was incomplete. I felt like so much was missing. Maybe I’m being generous with my rating, but everything that I appreciated, I did so too much to think of this book as ‘‘okay’’ only.

Advertisements

8 thoughts on “Review: Manga Classics: The Scarlet Letter by Stacy King, Nathaniel Hawthorne, Crystal Chan & SunNeko Lee

  1. Interesting review!
    I would recommend reading The Scarlet Letter, if you’re still interested after reading this version 🙂 I enjoyed it.

    If you’re interested, Pearl seems to not recognise her mother when she removes the scarlet A from her chest because Hester has become so associated with the letter that she loses her identity. She is only thought about in terms of her ‘crime’ 🙂

    Like

  2. I’ve studied Hawthorne at Uni but I haven’t read The Scarlett Letter even though I want to. This whole manga classics sounds like a fun way to read classics but as you said, after reading the original one. Lovely review, Lola!

    Like

  3. I’ve never actually read a manga before. A sad but true fact 😦 I’m glad you liked this one. I never read The Scarlet Letter so I think it’s best if I read that before I read this book. Great review, Lola!

    Like

  4. This was interesting to read because I just bought the Pride & Prejudice Manga Classic. I’ve never read any before and the Scarlet Letter was another one I looked at. Have you read the Pride and Prejudice one? Do you have any other recommendations of manga to read? ❤ Bee @ Bee Reads Books

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s